The tortoise coordinates and the cauchy problem in the stable study of the Schwarzschild black hole ∗
نویسنده
چکیده
Generally, the Schwarzschild black hole was proved stable through two different methods: the mode-decomposition method and the integral method. In the paper, we show the integral method can only apply to the initial data vanishing at both the horizon and the spatial infinity. It can not treat the initial data only vanishing at the spatial infinity. We give an example to show the misleading information caused by the use of the tortoise coordinates in the perturbation equations. Subsequently, the perturbation equation in the Schwarzschild coordinates is shown not sufficient for the stable study. PACS: 0420-q, 04.07.Bw, 97.60.-s
منابع مشابه
The effect of the tortoise coordinate on the stable study of the Schwarzschild black hole ∗
Carefully analyze influence of the tortoise coordinates r∗ and t on the stable study of the Schwarzschild black hole. Actually, one should be cautious in using the compact property of the perturbation field: it is true only with respect with the coordinate r and proper time or ”good time”, not the tortoise coordinates r∗ and t. Therefore, the mathematical proof used in reference [7] is incorrec...
متن کاملKlein - Gordon equation and the stable problem in the Rindler space - time ∗
The Klein-Gordon equation in the Rindler space-time is studied carefully. It is shown that the stable properties depend on using what time coordinate to define the initial time. If we use the Rindler time, the scalar field is stable. Alternatively, if we use the Minkowski time, the scalar field may be regarded unstable to some extent. Furthermore, the complete extension of the Rindler space tim...
متن کامل0 60 80 45 v 1 9 A ug 2 00 6 The stable problem in the Rindler space - time ∗
We carefully study the stable problem of the Rindler space time by the scalar wave perturbation. Using the two different coordinate systems, the scalar wave equation is investigated. The results are different in these two cases. They are analyzed and compared in detail. The conclusions are: (a) the Rindler space time as a whole is not stable; (b) the Rindler space time could exist stably only a...
متن کاملar X iv : g r - qc / 0 51 11 21 v 1 2 2 N ov 2 00 5 Does the Schwarzschild black hole really exist ?
we use the Kruskal time coordinate T to define the initial time. By this way, it naturally divides the stable study into one connected with the two regions: the whitehole-connected region and the black-hole-connected region. The union of the two regions covers the Schwarzschild space-time (r ≥ 2m). We also obtain the very reasonable conclusion: the white-hole-connected region is instable; where...
متن کاملar X iv : g r - qc / 0 50 90 30 v 1 9 S ep 2 00 5 Reconsideration of the Regge - Wheeler equation ∗
Reconsideration of the Regge-Wheeler equation is processed by using the Painlevé coordinate and ”good” timelier to define the initial time. We find that: the ReggeWheeler equation could has positive imaginary frequency. Because the Regge-Wheeler equation is the odd (angular) perturbation to the Schwarzschild black hole, the conclusion is that the Schwarzschild black hole is unstable with respec...
متن کامل